How Does Toyota Tundra Compare to GMC Sierra?

2025 Toyota Tundra vs. 2025 GMC Sierra 1500
General Comparison
Toyota Tundra has long held a reputation for durability and longevity and low cost of ownership. Tundra has received multiple awards from Kelley Blue book to support this: it received the 2024 award for best resale value of any full-size truck, as well as the full-size truck with the lowest 5-year cost of ownership.
However, the full-size truck segment is fiercely competitive, and one of the most popular types of vehicles in America. There are several strong contenders in the class, including the GMC Sierra. In this comparison we’ll look at how Toyota Tundra offers a stronger choice in half-ton pickups in capability and value. Let’s explore.
Toyota Tundra | GMC Sierra 1500 | |
---|---|---|
Base MSRP, Double Cabs | $40,090 | $43,595 |
Standard Engine | 3.4L TT V6 | 2.7L turbo I4 |
Standard Horsepower | 358 | 310 |
Standard MPG, city/hwy/comb. | 18/24/20 | 18/21/19 |
Max Available Horsepower | 437 | 420 |
Max Available Torque | 583 lb-ft | 495 lb-ft |
Standard Infotainment | 8″ touchscreen | 7″ touchscreen |
Satellite Radio | Standard | Available |
Available Hybrid | Yes | No |
IIHS 2024 Top Safety Pick+ | Yes | No |
Complimentary Maintenance | 2 yrs/25,000 miles | 1 yr/12,000 miles |
Performance & Efficiency
Compared to GMC Sierra, Tundra starts with a larger, more powerful engine standard. GMC Sierra 1500 features a turbocharged 2.7L four-cylinder engine as standard, while the Tundra features a twin turbo 3.4L V6 with 358 horsepower as its standard engine.
Toyota Tundra also offers the option of a hybrid powerplant that doesn’t sacrifice performance, with the i-FORCE MAX option. With this powertrain, the Tundra has a superior horsepower rating compared to Sierra. This figure reaches 437 hp vs. GMC’s 420 hp with the 6.2L V8. Further, a Sierra so equipped is rated for an estimated 17 mpg combined, lower than a Tundra i-FORCE MAX’s estimated 20 mpg.
Torque is another figure that is important in half-ton trucks when it comes to hauling, whether a full bed of equipment or when towing trailers. Tundra with i-FORCE MAX also has the edge over GMC Sierra, achieving an impressive 583 lb-ft of torque. The maximum torque rating for Sierra requires the option of a diesel engine, but is still lower than Toyota, at 495 lb-ft.
Verdict: The Toyota Tundra offers superior performance abilities, with more standard and available horsepower, more available torque, and still the benefit of great fuel efficiency for a half-ton pickup with an available hybrid.
Value & Safety
Tundra provides excellent value among large pickups as well. With extensive standard feature list, Tundra has much to offer at a competitive price. For example, it features a larger touchscreen standard compared to Sierra, 8″ vs. 7″, and also features standard SiriusXM satellite radio – an optional feature on Sierra. Part of Tundra’s value for the money is beyond just features however: Tundra features a standard Double Cab, allowing room for passengers or dry, lockable storage in the cab. Base GMC Sierras begin with a regular cab, and when moving up to a comparable Double Cab, Sierra starts at a higher base price than Tundra. This is also true of 4WD examples of crew cab pickups, where Tundra starts at $45,035 to Sierra’s $46,895.
Value also comes from safety and peace of mind. Toyota excels here as well, as the 2025 Tundra was named a Top Safety Pick+ by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, an award that GMC Sierra did not receive. Tundra’s safety is enhanced by standard Toyota Safety Sense.
Verdict: The Toyota Tundra offers more popular build varieties for a lower starting price, plus a better safety rating among popular large pickups.
Conclusion
While the GMC Sierra 1500 remains a popular large truck choice, the Toyota Tundra is gaining in the segment and it’s easy to see why. Tundra offers extra power, greater efficiency, more safety, and more value. Projected cost of ownership with Tundra is lower than any other large pickup. Part of Tundra’s value comes from ToyotaCare, which provides complimentary maintenance for a longer period than Sierra: 2 years/25,000 miles, to the 1 year/12,000 miles from GMC. With these lower expected ownership costs, Tundra gives you more of what truck buyers want in a value-packed workhorse.
Pinehurst Toyota in Southern Pines goes further with the peace of mind provided by the Advantage Plan. Call, text or visit us today to see the capable Tundra for yourself. Or see our other new Toyota comparisons to see how the full lineup stacks up. We look forward to helping you!